Lets Talk J.Jill Tall

I must confess: I have never shopped at J.Jill before, which makes this a blind date review. Like a typical first date, I’ve seen the photos online and have jumped to conclusions before we meet.

This gal, J.Jill — I think she goes for comfort first. The soft cotton blends and the loose, easy shapes seem like styles that would gravitate towards the front of your closet, especially when you’re feeling less than your fighting shape.

I am, however, a bit anxious. Although I enthusiastically support national retailers offering a tall section on their website (and maybe in brick-and-mortar stores someday?), I often wonder who decides how tall is tall? On the size guide section of J.Jill, the tall section reads, “For women 5’ 7 1/2” or taller.”

5’7’’ is tall? Ladies, we must be skyscrapers.

Mild joking aside, this Silk Forward-Seam Shirt I met today from J.Jill is handsome. The sleeves are long enough for my 72-inch wingspan to raise my arms without exposing my wrists. The shirt sits low enough on the hips so that if I were to uncharacteristically raise my arms yet again, my belly would not show its button.

The plum color of this shirt is tonally more reddish than I was expecting, but it’s quite flattering against a variety of backgrounds. This shirt is one of those shirts that look good photographed, so wear it on a day when you expect to be snapped.

Katie Henner Photoshoot with Photographer Kyle Blair in Los Angeles, California for The Tall Society.

For trousers, I’ve settled into a pair of J. Jill’s Perfect Cotton-Stretch Print Ankle Pants in “Breeze Textured Paisley.” After Diane von Furstenberg’s printed wrap dresses inspired a thousand knockoffs, I swore off all prints but am now gently considering them. I’m really digging this print, especially when juxtaposed with an unexpected red top instead of the basic black or white tank.

Katie Henner Photoshoot with Photographer Kyle Blair in Los Angeles, California for The Tall Society.

Tall ladies, please be aware that this is an ankle-length pant. It’s not full length, so it’s going to hit your leg a bit higher. With ankle-length pants, you’re supposed to break out the heels and show off your sexy feet tops. Shaving is, as always, optional.

I do find that the rise of this pant is a bit ill-fitting on me. I wonder if 1) the retailer is measuring a 5’7’’ fit model and only adding a couple of inches to the inseam instead of adjusting for the rise (waist to crotch = rise) of a taller woman or 2) I just need to order up a size.

Pardon me while I slip into my next outfit. She’s a dress.

Is it me or have you noticed the word “Tencel” popping up lately in mainstream fashion? Tencel is actually a branded version of the fiber lyocell, a man-made fabric similar to rayon or bamboo that is environmentally sustainable. Tencel fabric tends to drape well and is less prone to wrinkles.

Katie Henner Photoshoot with Photographer Kyle Blair in Los Angeles, California for The Tall Society.

This Tencel-Soft Indigo A-Line Dress blends 88% Tencel with 12% linen into a 40 1/2” length that hits above the (tall) knee. The fabric feels soft and buttery, like a dream pair of denim I bought 12 years ago at Paper Denim + Cloth, but can’t fit into and only keep because the fabric is a marker of what I want clothing to feel like. In short, this dress feels far softer than your typical starchy denim piece.

Katie Henner Photoshoot with Photographer Kyle Blair in Los Angeles, California for The Tall Society.

This dress might have the potential to be one of those dresses that no one knows you secretly wear everyday because you’ve styled it differently with ever-changing layers and accessories. Here I’ve tied a thin leather belt to cinch my waist and slipped on a pair of less-than-white Velcro sneakers for an afternoon of exploring murals in downtown LA. It’s over 90 degrees F, and this dress is kindly absorbing my sweat.

As you can see from my relaxed expressions, I’m enjoying the fit of this easy, breezy dress. This is a dress to play in during the last dog days of summer and into the fall.

Outfit Details:
Silk Forward-Seam Shirt in Plum – Size Medium Tall
Perfect Cotton-Stretch Print Ankle Pants in Breeze Textured Paisley –  Size 12 Tall
Tencel-Soft Indigo A-Line Dress – Size Medium Tall

I might wear this dress again tomorrow. It was a pleasure, J.Jill.

Photo Credit: Kyle Blair


This post contains affiliate links.

Sharing is Caring
You may also like

Hey there Tall Sister, lets stay connected!




The Tall Society is an empowering and inspiring community created to unite tall girls and women worldwide.

You will find meaningful discussions and access to positivity and encouragement through all the content we create with love for our community.

Welcome home, Tall Sisters!

Meet the Team | Attend Our Next Event


  • Grab your sweatshirt and let the print do the talking, especially curated for our #TallTribe #TheTallSociety #TallTribe #PlusIsEqual #CelebrateMySize #BodyPositivity #TallGirl #TallStyle #realbeauty #InstaStyle #Brunch #MeetUps #TeamTall #tallgirl #tallwomen #tallbopo #tallgirlproblems #tallpeopleproblems #tallmodel #tallpeople #Tallfashion #Events
  • Share with your fav Tall and fabulous Tall Sister!
  • To all my Tall Sisters, you are beautiful, powerful and unique! Thank you for being on this ride with us here at The Tall Society.
  • Lots of shoes in extended size for all of you # TallSisters only on TheTallExchange.com
  • We have new and pre-loved dresses at The Tall Exchange. Check out linkin.bio
  • #TallTribe remember this day? Beautiful memories indeed! (LinkInBio) #TheTallSociety #TallTribe #PlusIsEqual #CelebrateMySize #BodyPositivity #TallGirl #TallStyle #realbeauty #InstaStyle #Brunch #MeetUps #TeamTall #tallgirl #tallwomen #tallbopo #tallgirlproblems #tallpeopleproblems #tallmodel #tallpeople #Tallfashion #Events
  • Why do Tall girls strike fear in the hearts of men? 😏
  • Beautiful dresses for beautiful sisters starting from $10 only at The Tall Exchange. #TheTallSociety #TallTribe #PlusIsEqual #CelebrateMySize #BodyPositivity #TallGirl #TallStyle #realbeauty #InstaStyle #Brunch #MeetUps #TeamTall #tallgirl #tallwomen #tallbopo #tallgirlproblems #tallpeopleproblems #tallmodel #tallpeople #Tallfashion #Events




Search The Tall Society